Two agencies quoted me to run my Amazon PPC: a $2,000/mo base, or a base plus 5% of ad-attributed sales. The math, and when an agency makes sense.
I've sat through agency pitches for my own brand, Rowdy Rooster Woodworks. I didn't sign with either one — and what they quoted is the reason this article exists. Fair warning: I sell PPC software, so I have an obvious bias here. The bias is real. The numbers below are also real — they're what I was actually quoted, against what my account actually spends.
What I was actually quoted
Two agencies, two structures, both built so your growth becomes their raise:
- Agency one: $2,000 up front, then a $500/month “software fee,” plus 5% of ad-attributed sales — including the sales my existing campaigns were already producing before they touched anything. The pitch was a loop — the same script circling the same close, mostly aimed at the revenue I’d already built.
- Agency two: $2,000/month as a base, moving to 5% of ad-attributed sales once the percentage outgrew that base. Their headline case study was a single discovery exercise on a coffee brand’s product title — and the pitch deck used fabricated Amazon listings as examples. Mockups dressed up as real accounts.
Neither is a percentage of ad spend — they’re a percentage of sales. That’s what most “agency cost” breakdowns miss: the fee is charged on revenue, not on the profit that revenue produced. Two accounts with identical ad sales pay identical fees whether one is comfortably profitable and the other is running at break-even. (What that works out to against real margins.)
What that would have cost my account
Rowdy Rooster runs about $4,700/month in ad spend and roughly $13,600/month in ad-attributed sales — an ACoS in the mid-30s, a normal account, not a fire to put out.
- Agency one: ~$500/month base + 5% of $13,600 ≈ $1,180/month, plus $2,000 up front — about $16,000 in year one.
- Agency two: the $2,000/month base = $24,000/year. At my volume 5% comes to well under the base, so the base is what I’d actually pay.
- The software that does the repetitive work: $129/month, $1,548/year.
That’s a $14,000–$22,000/year gap on an account my size — and the agency version comes with less visibility into your own account, not more.
The hidden costs nobody quotes
- Opacity — you stop seeing every change and the reasoning behind it. You’re paying for advertising you can no longer fully see.
- Lock-in — many agencies rebuild your campaign structure to their templates on day one. Leave, and your historical data and structure leave with them.
- A misaligned meter — when the fee is a percentage of sales, nobody on the other side has a reason to reduce your waste. (More on that dynamic.)
When an agency actually makes sense
I won’t tell you software is always the answer — that would undercut the honesty this whole piece is built on. An agency earns its keep when you reach the brand authority where multiple advertising motions matter at once — DSP, multi-channel, genuinely specialist work.
But if you’re a seller doing $5,000–$20,000/month in ad spend, you almost certainly don’t need agency structure. The work is repetitive and rule-shaped, not strategic. It varies brand to brand — but at that level, an agency is usually selling convenience at a steep markup, not expertise you couldn’t apply yourself. Before you sign with anyone, audit your own account first — most sellers find the agency would mostly be doing work they can already see and do themselves.
What we built instead
Roughly 80% of what an agency does month to month is repetitive — bid adjustments, negating wasted search terms, harvesting converters, budget management. That’s what RedHen Labs automates with rule-based automation: every change logged, every one reversible, nothing applied without your say-so. Unless you’re a seller well outside the range above, that’s all the management the account actually needs.
The other 20% — strategy, new launches, category expansion — is work you’re better positioned to do anyway. Nobody understands your products and your margins like you do. Try it free for 14 days.
.png){kind=small}
Partner